Free Web Hosting by Netfirms
Web Hosting by Netfirms | Free Domain Names by Netfirms

Focus on Fiqah

Home ] Up ] Next ]

Focus on Fiqah
(Your questions answered)

Your questions answered: Questions may also be sent to:
Al-Farouq Iftaa Department, PO Box 8072, Schauderville, 6060, South Africa

Q) Will Christians and Jews remain in jahannum eternally?
A
) Almighty Allah states in The Glorious Quran: “Those who reject faith and commit injustice, Allah is not prepared to forgive them nor to guide them to any path; except the path of Jahannum, to dwell therein eternally. And this is easy upon Allah.” (Surah Nisaa, verses 168, 169) In another place Allah Ta’ala says: “Verily Allah has cursed the Unbelievers and prepared for them a Blazing Fire; to dwell therein eternally. No protector will they find nor any helper.” (Surah Ahzaab, verses 64, 65) These two verses contain the Arabic term abadan which means eternally or forever. This is clear proof that kuffar will inhabit Hell eternally, never to exit. Another confirmation of this is the Statement of Allah in Surah Baqarah: “And they shall not emerge from the Fire (of Hell),” (verse 167). On this basis the Ahle Sunnah wal Jamaah have formed their belief that those who perished in the state of unbelief (kufr) shall not be granted reprieve from Hell-fire, nor shall they emerge therefrom after admittance.

Q) Why the need for a Shaikh when we have the Quran and Hadith to follow, and why the need for bay'at? Each Shaikh has a different formula as regards zikr, etc., but Allah has one set of rules. Please explain.
A)
THE NEED FOR A SHAIKH: There is no science or skill achievable in this world without the help of a guide. The most talented person stands in need of a more experienced mentor and tutor. The same applies to Islamic discipline and practice. This has been the age-old system devised by Allah and implemented by His Rasool (sallallahu alaihi wasallam) for the spiritual advancement and benefit of this Ummah. All the great Ulema of past achieved what they did through their teachers and spiritual guides. The teacher or Ustaad imparts the knowledge of Deen, while the spiritual guide or Shaikh provides the methods of practicing on that knowledge. Rasoolullah sallallahu alaihi wasallam was the Shaikh of the Sahaaba, hence they always turned to him for guidance and enlightenment. Ever since, this system of Shaikh and Mureed has been practiced upon over the centuries. The one definite reason for the moral decadence of Muslims is the lack of someone who can guide them spiritually. We all are spiritually bankrupt and morally embarrassed, so we need one who can uplift us by providing that special coaching for the ailing soul. The Shaikh is one who himself has undergone spiritual training and is, therefore, in a position to train others. The Shaikh is able to detect the hidden faults of his disciple and provide treatment accordingly. The follower (mureed) will at times be confused, perplexed, frustrated, stressed out, and in great anxiety, either through worldly or religious causes, and the Shaikh will provide him with spiritual treatment to overcome these difficulties.

THE BAY’AT: The bay’at is a sunnah practice established from several ahadeeth narrated by Imam Bukhari and others. In a separate article we will furnish these ahadeeth insha-Allah. The purpose of the bay’at is to commit the mureed to a process of spiritual reformation. The rules of Allah are certainly all the same, but the methods to make practicing on those rules easy will differ from individual to individual. We all perform the same salaah. However, some people will do so out of fear for Hell, while others do so out of hope in Jannat, and yet others simply offer the salah because it is the law of Allah. The more advanced Muslims will perform salaah out of love for Allah. It is the duty and function of the Shaikh to understand his follower and apply the appropriate method to lure him towards that ibaadat. Obviously such a task is enormous and requires the work of an experienced guide. This is what the concept of tasowwuf is all about. Terms such as tasowwuf, bay’at, islaah, mureed, are merely technical words used to describe the aspects of this science, just as terms like saheeh, hasan, dha’eef, mursal, musnad, are used in the science of hadith to describe different categories of hadith. It is foolish and unreasonable to reject a science simply because we don’t understand or accept the technical terms. It is also unreasonable to demand proof of such technical terms from Quran and Hadith, for then all sciences of Deen like etymology and syntax (sarf and nahu), aqaaid, etc, will be rejected because these technical terms are not found in the Quran and Hadith. The reality of the matter is that these branches of Islamic learning are all used to enhance our understanding and practice on Deen, without which we cannot be complete Muslims.

Q) We intend building a jaamat khana on the first floor of our building. However, under the jamaat khana are toilets. Is there anything wrong in this?
A)
There is nothing wrong as far as the law of Shariah is concerned, in having toilets beneath an ibaadat khana. This would not be proper though, if a Musjid was being erected.

Q) In Taraweeh, can the Imam leave out the thana to make the salah shorter?
A)
The Imam should not leave out the thana, but may curtail his durood and dua. In other words, he may recite a short durood and dua, not leaving these out entirely.

Q) I forgot to read my thana. Is my salah valid?
A)
Yes, your salah is valid. Thana is sunnat, and omitting a sunnat does not nullify the salah, nor does it necessitate sajda sahu.


FATWAS OF HAZRAT MOULANA ASHRAF ALI THANWI (RA)

Q: A practice prevalent in our area is that when goods are purchased from a merchant, he is required to deliver the goods to the house or shop of the buyer. Sometimes delivery is free (as part and parcel of the sale) and sometimes he charges for delivery. Is such a transaction valid?
A:
Basically such a transaction is not valid (due to the condition of delivery being incorporated into the sale). However, where this practice is prevalent and widespread, due to the principal of Ta’amul this will be allowed, (whether delivery is free or is charged for).
Editor’s Note: Ta’amul means the general and prevalent trend among Muslims of a certain country or region. (Imdadul Fataawa, vol. 3, p. 22)

Q: A man died and left behind some properties as part of his estate. One of the heirs sold his share in those properties before taking physical possession of the share he inherited. Is this permissible? Is there a difference in the ruling between movable and immovable property?
A:
The sale of such a share as mentioned above is Jaiz (permissible), whether it be the sale of movable or immovable property. There is no difference in this ruling among the (Hanafi) Jurists. However, movable property that was purchased from another, not inherited, cannot be sold to another (i.e. a third party) before taking physical possession. (Imdadul Fataawa, vol. 3, p. 34)

Q: What do the respected Ulema say regarding the selling of Zam Zam water? Is it permissible to trade in Zam Zam water?
A:
There is apparently no Shar’ee factor prohibiting such trade. Zam Zam is a valuable commodity and one who brings it out of Makka becomes the valid owner. He is thus selling his own, legal property, hence jaiz. Being sacred and holy is not negatory to selling it. There is nothing more sacred than The Quran, yet, selling Qurans is completely lawful, so likewise here. (Imdadul Fataawa, vol. 3, p. 115)

Q: Upon awaking from sleep at about 10 o clock in the morning I noticed that I needed a bath. I performed ghusl and read my Zuhr salah. After salah I entered the toilet to pass urine, and as I was doing so I noticed several drops of mani (semen) coming out with the urine. Do I have to repeat my ghusl and salah?
A:
Your Zuhr salah was valid, since the flowing of drops of semen only occurred after the salah. As for the ghusl, a rule to remember is that after taking a bath from ihtilaam or sexual intercourse, if one had walked around a good deal, or had passed urine and then had a bath, such a ghusl will not be broken by the emergence of a few drops of semen afterwards. Otherwise you would have to repeat the ghusl. (Vol. 1, p.20)

Q: It is stated in some books that ghusl for Arafah is mustahab. Does this apply for only those who are in Hajj, or for all people?
A:
From the book Raddul-Muhtaar it is derived that this ghusl is mustahab for all Muslims, not only the hujjaj.

Q: Is it permissible to trim the moustache, cut nails, or shave off pubic hair whilst one is in the state of janaabat (impurity)? Is it true that when hair and nails are removed whilst one is na-paak then these parts of the body remain in the state of janaabat and will complain to Allah on the Day of Qiyamat that this person had left us in the state of janaabat (by separating us from the body before taking a bath)?
A:
It is stated in the book Hidayatun Noor of Moulana Sa’dullah that to remove hair and nails in the state of ritual impurity (janaabat) is makrooh. However, I have not come across this belief anywhere (that the hair and nails will complain to Allah on qiyamat). In any case it does appear to be false.


  • All progress is dependant upon remaining steadfast on the Shariah.

  • Earning is not in your control, but spending is.

Extracted from: Words of Worth (Hazrat Maseehul Ummat)